BMW S 1000 R (up to 2024): Strengths and Weaknesses - Rider Insights

"Leave us your experiences in the comments" isn't just a throwaway line that we tag onto the end of a 1000PS video. No one can provide a deeper insight into the essence of a motorcycle than its owner. That's why your comments are so valuable. We've sifted through comments from numerous BMW S 1000 R videos to compile your experiences in this report.

The BMW S 1000 R was introduced in 2014 as the naked bike version of the successful supersport model, the S 1000 RR. It borrowed many technical elements from the RR, including the powerful inline-four engine, but was optimized for road use. With a restricted output of 160 hp and a focus on handling, everyday usability, and comfort, it quickly became a popular model in the power-naked segment. Over the years, the S 1000 R has undergone several updates, with significant modernizations in design and electronics. The latest models offer 165 hp, extensive rider assist features, and reduced weight to meet the demands of modern riders. It is regarded as a versatile machine that combines sporty dynamics with touring capability.

You can find our tests here: BMW S 1000 R Reviews on 1000PS.

Based on YouTube comments, the following strengths of the S 1000 R stand out:

Ride Performance: The BMW S 1000 R impresses with precise handling that provides fun for riders of all experience levels. With 165 hp, it offers ample power for the open road, while the quickshifter ensures seamless gear changes.

Comfort: Improved ergonomics, a wide steering angle, and a low center of gravity make the bike easily accessible and comfortable for smaller riders as well.

Technology and Features: Modern electronics like wheelie control, Dynamic Pro mode, and an easy-to-use TFT display set the S 1000 R apart. Low-maintenance components and fuel efficiency are additional advantages.

Design: The aesthetics are well-received, though the second generation is considered by some to be less characterful compared to its predecessor.

Value for Money: BMW offers a lot of equipment and quality at a competitive price.

Owners also report weaknesses or issues with the Bavarian naked bike:

Aesthetics: The headlight design (regardless of generation) and the large catalytic converter aren't to everyone's taste and are perceived as distracting.

Emotionless Response: The technical perfection leaves some riders feeling a lack of emotion and "character."

Engine Characteristics: The inline-four is considered powerful but lacking in character. Vibrations and a tame sound diminish the riding fun.

Sound: The exhaust sounds functional but not emotional. Many riders miss a robust, exciting sound.

Equipment: The choice of components like brakes is criticized as not high-quality enough, especially compared to competitors.

Additional Costs: Extra features significantly drive up the price, which deters some riders.

The BMW S 1000 R is a modern naked bike that scores with its precise ride dynamics, well-thought-out ergonomics, and impressive technical features. It offers strong performance, intuitive handling, and an attractive price-performance ratio, making it an excellent choice for spirited road riders. Particularly praiseworthy is the well-tuned electronics, which provide both beginners and experienced riders with a safe and comfortable riding experience.

Nevertheless, there are criticisms that leave some riders with mixed feelings. The design, particularly the headlight and catalytic converter, isn't positively received by everyone. The engine, despite being powerful, is seen by some as lacking emotional character and sound.

The BMW S 1000 R is ideal for sporty riders looking for a precise, powerful, and comfortable motorcycle for country roads. Thanks to its light handling, ergonomic seating, and modern technology, it's also suitable for beginners and smaller riders. Comfort features like heated grips and the low-maintenance Endurance chain appeal to touring riders who value everyday practicality. Its attractive price-performance ratio makes it particularly interesting for buyers who appreciate modern features at a fair price. However, those seeking more emotionality, a distinctive sound, or premium components might be better served by competitor models.