BMW S 1000 XR 2017 vs. BMW R 1250 GS 2021
BMW S 1000 XR 2017
BMW R 1250 GS 2021
Overview - BMW S 1000 XR 2017 vs BMW R 1250 GS 2021
The BMW S 1000 XR 2017 and the BMW R 1250 GS 2021 are both exceptional motorcycles, each with their own unique strengths and weaknesses.
Starting with the BMW S 1000 XR 2017, this sport touring motorcycle boasts a powerful in-line 4-cylinder engine with a displacement of 999cc. It delivers an impressive 165 horsepower and 114 Nm of torque, providing exhilarating acceleration and top speed. The engine is paired with a chain transmission and features an electric starter for convenience. The bike's aluminum twin tube frame ensures stability and durability. The front suspension consists of a telescopic fork with adjustable compression and rebound, while the rear suspension is a swing arm with the same adjustment capabilities. The S 1000 XR is equipped with double disk brakes at the front, utilizing radial technology for enhanced stopping power. Advanced rider assistance systems such as ABS and traction control further enhance safety. The bike features a 17-inch front tire and a 17-inch rear tire, with widths of 120mm and 190mm respectively. The wheelbase measures 1548mm, providing stability during high-speed maneuvers. The seat height is set at 840mm, which may be a bit low for taller riders. The S 1000 XR weighs 228kg and has a fuel tank capacity of 20 liters. Overall, the S 1000 XR offers a powerful and precise riding experience, with strong brakes and engine, and a range of accessories and HP Parts available.
On the other hand, the BMW R 1250 GS 2021 is an enduro motorcycle designed for off-road adventures. It features a boxer engine with a displacement of 1254cc, delivering 136 horsepower and 143 Nm of torque. The engine is paired with a prop shaft transmission, ensuring smooth power delivery. The bike has a 2-cylinder configuration and a 4-stroke engine. The front suspension consists of a telelever system with preload adjustment, while the rear suspension is a single swing arm with preload and rebound adjustment. The R 1250 GS features a steel frame, providing stability and durability. It is equipped with double disk brakes at the front, utilizing radial technology for enhanced braking performance. In addition to ABS and traction control, the bike also offers advanced rider assistance systems such as anti-slipping control, hill start assist, riding modes, cornering ABS, ride by wire, and traction control. The front tire has a width of 120mm and a diameter of 19 inches, while the rear tire has a width of 170mm and a diameter of 17 inches. The wheelbase measures 1525mm, providing stability on various terrains. The seat height is set at 850mm, which may be slightly high for shorter riders. The R 1250 GS weighs 249kg and has a fuel tank capacity of 20 liters. Overall, the R 1250 GS offers great ride comfort and ergonomics, a powerful engine, and a range of practical riding aids.
BMW S 1000 XR 2017
In terms of strengths, the BMW S 1000 XR 2017 offers a power increase over its predecessor, with a strong engine and brakes. It also comes with decent standard equipment and offers extensive accessories, including numerous HP Parts. The bike's handling is precise and stable, providing confidence during cornering and high-speed riding.
On the other hand, the BMW R 1250 GS 2021 excels in ride comfort and ergonomics, making it suitable for long-distance touring. The bike's powerful engine ensures smooth acceleration and a confident feel in the saddle. The R 1250 GS also offers a great connectivity app and an easy-to-read display, enhancing the overall riding experience. The bike's versatile chassis accommodates every route, making it suitable for both on-road and off-road adventures. It is also praised for its practical riding aids.
BMW R 1250 GS 2021
However, both motorcycles have their weaknesses. The BMW S 1000 XR 2017 may feel somewhat wide in the leg area due to its 4-cylinder configuration. The handlebars are also quite wide, which may not be ideal for riders with narrower shoulders. Additionally, shorter riders may find the low seat height necessary, which could affect their comfort and riding position.
On the other hand, the BMW R 1250 GS 2021 has been criticized for its rough overall appearance, which may not appeal to all riders. Some riders have also found the gearshifts at low revs to be somewhat clumsy, requiring extra effort to engage smoothly.
In conclusion, both the BMW S 1000 XR 2017 and the BMW R 1250 GS 2021 offer exceptional performance and features. The S 1000 XR excels in power and handling, while the R 1250 GS offers great comfort and versatility. Riders should consider their specific preferences and riding needs when choosing between these two impressive motorcycles.
Technical Specifications BMW S 1000 XR 2017 compared to BMW R 1250 GS 2021
Pros and Cons in comparison
Pros and Cons in comparison
BMW S 1000 XR 2017
The S 1000 XR, with its now 165 hp Supersport power unit combined with the geometry and comfort of a Bigenduro, is one of the fastest motorbikes on the public road. The extensive range of accessories makes it even faster or even more comfortable, as required. However, with a seat height of 840 mm and a long crotch arch, it is only conditionally suitable for smaller riders. The 790 mm high seat, however, remedies this. The brakes are as strong as the engine, the XR convinces with precision and above all stability. Despite the insane performance, you feel well and safe, as you would expect from a BMW.
BMW R 1250 GS 2021
The GS also impressed us with its versatility during the test in November 2021. We rode the bike on a wide variety of terrain and were once again very satisfied. The motorbike convinces in every situation with its easy handling and practicality. On the other hand, it can also be ridden delightfully irrationally.
Price Comparison Avarage Market Price BMW S 1000 XR vs BMW R 1250 GS
There are a few key differences between a BMW S 1000 XR 2017 and a BMW R 1250 GS 2021. In terms of price, the actual average price of a BMW R 1250 GS 2021 is about 41% higher. A BMW S 1000 XR 2017 experiences a loss of 700 USD in one year of ownership. This is offset by a loss of 350 USD for a BMW R 1250 GS 2021. Compared to BMW R 1250 GS 2021 there are less BMW S 1000 XR 2017 bikes available on the 1000PS.de Marketplace, specifically 20 compared to 66. It takes less time to sell a BMW R 1250 GS with 55 days compared to 112 days for the BMW S 1000 XR. Since model year 2015 1000PS.de editors have written 40 reviews for the BMW S 1000 XR and 50 reviews for the BMW R 1250 GS since model year 2019. The first review for the BMW S 1000 XR was published on 10/21/2014 and now has more than 16,000 views. This compares to more than 305,600 views for the first review on BMW R 1250 GS published on 9/19/2018.
