BMW S 1000 XR 2021 vs. BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

BMW S 1000 XR 2021

BMW S 1000 XR 2021

BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

Loading...

Overview - BMW S 1000 XR 2021 vs BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

The BMW S 1000 XR 2021 and the BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023 are both impressive motorcycles, each with their own unique strengths and weaknesses.

Starting with the BMW S 1000 XR 2021, it boasts a powerful in-line four-cylinder engine that delivers 165 HP and 114 Nm of torque. This engine provides a broad usable rev band and is known for its rev-happy nature. The bike's electronic chassis with automatic load recognition ensures a well-balanced ride, even with a pillion passenger. The S 1000 XR also features riding modes that allow for a change in response behavior, making it suitable for various riding conditions. Additionally, the bike has good brakes, ensuring reliable stopping power.

BMW S 1000 XR 2021

BMW S 1000 XR 2021

However, the S 1000 XR does have a few weaknesses. The knee angle on long tours may be a bit narrow for taller riders, potentially causing discomfort. The suspension damping is not sensitive enough, making it difficult to find a truly comfortable setup. Additionally, the bike's consumption is on the higher side.

On the other hand, the BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023 offers a high-torque engine that accelerates strongly from low revs. With 136 HP and 143 Nm of torque, this bike provides a powerful and responsive ride. Its low center of gravity ensures surprisingly accessible maneuverability, making it easy to handle in various situations. The R 1250 GS Adventure also boasts practical details for frequent riders, such as a heated seat and great wind and weather protection. The bike has a remarkable range of 600 km and boasts low fuel consumption. It offers great ride comfort, powerful engine, and excellent electronics. The display is easy to read, and the bike provides a confident feeling in the saddle. It also features practical riding aids and great ergonomics, particularly for taller riders.

BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

However, the R 1250 GS Adventure does have a few weaknesses as well. The bike is relatively heavy, which may impact maneuverability in certain situations. The gearshifts at low revs can be somewhat clumsy, affecting the overall smoothness of the ride. Additionally, the bike has a jagged appearance with little elegance, which may not appeal to everyone. Lastly, the R 1250 GS Adventure can be quite expensive, especially with full equipment.

In conclusion, both the BMW S 1000 XR 2021 and the BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023 are impressive motorcycles with their own set of strengths and weaknesses. The S 1000 XR excels in its rev-happy engine, well-balanced ride, and riding modes, while the R 1250 GS Adventure stands out with its high-torque engine, maneuverability, practical details, and great range. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on individual preferences and priorities.

Technical Specifications BMW S 1000 XR 2021 compared to BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

BMW S 1000 XR 2021
BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

Engine and Drive Train

Engine typeEngine typeIn lineEngine typeBoxer
BoreBore80 mmBore102.5 mm
StrokeStroke49.7 mmStroke76 mm
Engine powerEngine power165 HPEngine power136 HP
Rpm at Max. PowerRpm at Max. Power11,000 rpmRpm at Max. Power7,750 rpm
TorqueTorque114 NmTorque143 Nm
Rpm at TorqueRpm at Torque9,250 rpmRpm at Torque6,250 rpm
Compression RatioCompression Ratio12.5 Compression Ratio12.5
Fuel systemFuel systemInjectionFuel systemInjection
StarterStarterElectricStarterElectric
Clutch TypeClutch TypeMultiplate in oil-bath, AntihoppingClutch TypeAntihopping
TransmissionTransmissionChainTransmissionProp shaft
Transmission TypeTransmission TypeGearshiftTransmission TypeGearshift
Number of gearsNumber of gears6Number of gears6
CylindersCylinders4Cylinders2
StrokesStrokes4-StrokeStrokes4-Stroke
Valves per cylinderValves per cylinder4Valves per cylinder4
CoolingCoolingliquidCoolingliquid-air
DisplacementDisplacement999 ccmDisplacement1,254 ccm

Suspension Front

Front suspensionFront suspensionUpside-Down telescopic forkFront suspensionTelelever
DiameterDiameter45 mmDiameter37 mm
TravelTravel150 mmTravel210 mm
AdjustmentAdjustmentCompression, Preload, ReboundAdjustmentPreload

Suspension Rear

SuspensionSuspensionSwing armSuspensionSingle swing arm
Shock absorberShock absorberMonoshockShock absorberMonoshock
TravelTravel150 mmTravel220 mm
AdjustmentAdjustmentCompression, Preload, ReboundAdjustmentPreload, Rebound
MaterialMaterialAluminiumMaterialAluminium

Chassis

FrameFrameAluminiumFrameSteel
Frame typeFrame typeTwin Tube, Load-bearing engineFrame typeLoad-bearing engine
RakeRake65.1 degreeRake65.1 degree
TrailTrail116 mmTrail95.4 mm

Brakes Front

TypeTypeDouble diskTypeDouble disk
DiameterDiameter320 mmDiameter305 mm
PistonPistonFour pistonsPistonFour pistons
TechnologyTechnologyradialTechnologyradial

Brakes Rear

TypeTypeDiscTypeDisc
DiameterDiameter220 mmDiameter276 mm
PistonPistonSingle pistonPistonDouble piston
Shock mountShock mountFloating caliperShock mountFloating caliper

Assistance Systems

Advanced Rider Assistance SystemsAdvanced Rider Assistance SystemsSuspension electronically adjustable, Riding modes, Cornering ABS, Ride by Wire, Traction controlAdvanced Rider Assistance SystemsABS, Anti-slipping control, Hill start assist, Suspension electronically adjustable, Riding modes, Cornering ABS, Ride by Wire

Dimensions and Weights

Front tyre widthFront tyre width120 mmFront tyre width120 mm
Front tyre heightFront tyre height70 %Front tyre height70 %
Front tyre diameterFront tyre diameter17 inchFront tyre diameter19 inch
Rear tyre widthRear tyre width190 mmRear tyre width170 mm
Rear tyre heightRear tyre height55 %Rear tyre height60 %
Rear tyre diameterRear tyre diameter17 inchRear tyre diameter17 inch
LengthLength2,333 mmLength2,270 mm
WidthWidth850 mmWidth980 mm
WheelbaseWheelbase1,552 mmWheelbase1,504 mm
Seat HeightSeat Height840 mmSeat Height890 mm
Kerb Weight (with ABS)Kerb Weight (with ABS)226 kgKerb Weight (with ABS)268 kg
Fuel Tank CapacityFuel Tank Capacity20 lFuel Tank Capacity30 l
License compliancyLicense compliancyALicense compliancyA

Equipment

EquipmentEquipmentLED daytime running lights, LED-Headlights, TFT display, Windscreen adjustableEquipmentCornering lights, LED daytime running lights, LED-Headlights, Heated seat, TFT display, Windscreen adjustable

Pros and Cons in comparison

Pros and Cons in comparison

BMW S 1000 XR 2021

BMW S 1000 XR 2021

The BMW S 1000 XR offers a pleasant touring motorbike on the basis of a super sports bike. Sounds like a compromise - but rides like a spot-on development. The motorbike is practical and mature. Wind and weather protection are very good, integration from the mobile phone is well tested and intuitive, and the engine is simply always a joy to ride. The chassis adapts well to the load condition, but it never becomes sensitive and really comfortable. The seat comfort is good, but the knee angle becomes a bit acute on long tours. Nevertheless, this is a great motorbike that you like to ride sportily, but also very far.

Riding modes change response behaviour suitable for practical use

great rev-happy four-cylinder engine with a broad usable rev band

well-balanced vehicle - also with pillion passenger - thanks to electronic chassis with automatic recognition of load condition

good brakes

Knee angle on long tours a bit narrow for tall people

suspension damping not sensitive enough - no really comfortable setup possible

consumption high

BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023

The big GS Adventure is and remains a great motorbike for any terrain - even for tight corners. The low centre of gravity of the boxer engine, the longitudinally mounted crankshaft, the upright seating position and the powerful but easily controllable torque from far below are simply a force. Although the Adventure version has a higher seat with more weight, which is a decisive hindrance when turning or manoeuvring, in terms of performance the engine also has so much punch in the big GS Adventure that you can let it rip. The BMW's braking system is stable and excellently controllable, and the equipment and electronics can be upgraded considerably - as long as you tick the boxes on the order list. Of course, this pushes up the price, but the many fans of the fat GS Adventure obviously don't mind.

High-torque engine that accelerates strongly from low revs

low centre of gravity ensures surprisingly accessible manoeuvrability

practical details for frequent riders on board

gigantic range of 600 km

amazingly low consumption

good wind and weather protection

great ride comfort

powerful engine

great electronics

easy-to-read display

confident feeling in the saddle

practical riding aids

great ergonomics for tall people.

High weight

gearshifts at low revs somewhat clumsy

jagged appearance with little elegance

high-priced with full equipment

Price Comparison Avarage Market Price BMW S 1000 XR vs BMW R 1250 GS Adventure

There are a few key differences between a BMW S 1000 XR 2021 and a BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023. In terms of price, the actual average price of a BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023 is about 24% higher. Compared to BMW R 1250 GS Adventure 2023 there are less BMW S 1000 XR 2021 bikes available on the 1000PS.de Marketplace, specifically 13 compared to 47. It takes less time to sell a BMW R 1250 GS Adventure with 64 days compared to 71 days for the BMW S 1000 XR. Since model year 2015 1000PS.de editors have written 40 reviews for the BMW S 1000 XR and 30 reviews for the BMW R 1250 GS Adventure since model year 2019. The first review for the BMW S 1000 XR was published on 10/21/2014 and now has more than 16,000 views. This compares to more than 43,300 views for the first review on BMW R 1250 GS Adventure published on 11/6/2018.

Price BMW S 1000 XR

Model year
Current average market prices

Price BMW R 1250 GS Adventure

Model year
Current average market prices

Alternative Comparisons

1000PS Partner

LOUISContinental MotorradreifenSchuberthcalimoto GmbHMotorex AG